Why I Am Unwilling to Celebrate China’s Technological Progress

Updated: Nov 13
One point must be acknowledged at the outset: in recent years, China’s achievements in science and technology have been striking by any global standard. Whether in artificial intelligence, robotics, electric vehicles, or a host of other fields, the country has been advancing at an astonishing pace. Many Chinese, as ever, take immense pride in these developments and feel a deep sense of national accomplishment. I, however, feel none of that pride. On the contrary, I find these developments deeply troubling. This is not because I am, as some would sneer, a hardened traitor who cannot bear to see Chinese people prosper. It is because I know that the more technologically advanced China becomes, the grimmer the future for Chinese people will be, the higher the cost of overthrowing the Communist Party, and the more remote any prospect of democracy will become.
A few months ago, a friend of mine in China sent me several videos and screenshots in obvious anger. Their contents were roughly as follows: in Hebei, the authorities had been aggressively enforcing a rural “coal-to-gas” conversion policy, yet the monthly heating costs — often running into several thousand yuan, and sometimes even over ten thousand — were far beyond what elderly villagers could possibly afford on their meagre pensions. Many were left with no choice but to endure the winter by piling on extra clothing. Yet when temperatures plunge to ten or even twenty degrees below zero, a few threadbare cotton coats are no defence against the cold. So, when they could bear it no longer, some would secretly burn coal or firewood for warmth. Ordinarily, this would simply be another familiar Chinese story of “where there is a policy from above, there is a countermeasure below”. But under Party rule, China’s technological progress has indeed become formidable, and the Party has long excelled at one particular art: when it tries to do something good, it leaves chaos in its wake; when it does something evil, it often does so with chilling efficiency.
Faced with this situation, the local authorities did not stop at the usual tactic of “encouraging neighbours to supervise and report on one another”. They also made the ingenious decision to deploy drones to patrol the villages, monitoring in real time whether any peasants were secretly burning coal or wood for heat. Once discovered, they would have their tools confiscated and be fined several thousand yuan. As a result, some elderly people, unable to afford gas and terrified of secretly burning wood, reportedly ended up freezing to death. In the twenty-first century, were such events to occur in any modern country, they would provoke a storm of public outrage. The media and the public alike would demand answers and hold the government to account. In China alone, the matter was swiftly scrubbed from the internet, banned from discussion, and the public reacted with a weary resignation, as though everyone had known all along that this would be the outcome. One can only conclude that whenever some appalling outrage, some act of cruelty devoid of conscience, is tied to the Communist Party, people suddenly seem to understand at once: oh, the Party did it — then there is nothing surprising here. Disperse. Move on.
Drone surveillance of villagers burning coal is only one tiny example of how technology can be turned against the people. Similar examples are too numerous to count. One such case involved what the Party itself once publicised in a video: so-called “remote-controlled armour”. A soldier wearing such equipment, once captured or rendered combat-ineffective, could have the armour remotely detonated by technicians in the rear in order to destroy it. It is a weapon system that treats human life as utterly expendable — straightforwardly inhuman in its logic. And yet the Party’s first instinct was apparently: how brilliant we are, let us show this off so that everyone may marvel. This terrorist cast of mind is so grotesque that, globally speaking, only the Chinese Communist Party and a small number of its fellow members in its so-called “league of justice” could produce such a way of thinking. It would be laughable were it not so horrifying. Naturally, once the video triggered public uproar, it too was deleted with the Party’s customary speed.
The hottest industry in the world today hardly needs naming: it is artificial intelligence. The development of AI is accelerating with every passing day, and the Party attaches enormous importance to it. Yet whereas other countries hope to use AI to improve productivity, the Party’s overriding ambition is to use it to consolidate its rule. Censorship and surveillance will therefore be central. Years ago, the Party was already using its notorious “Skynet” system to monitor the country in real time. With future advances in AI, coupled with the Party’s insistence that it stands above the law, one can easily imagine how much more unbearable life will become for dissidents. Privacy, for the individual, will cease to exist. Every word and every action will first be subjected to machine scrutiny.
Take WeChat as an example. For many years, its surveillance mechanisms appeared to operate primarily in group chats: messages inside groups were monitored in real time, and material involving pornography, violence, or content deemed harmful to the Party was swiftly censored and deleted. Private one-to-one chats still seemed, to a certain extent, to permit the exchange of more provocative images. Yet just last month, while chatting privately with a friend, I tried to send a parody image of Xi Jinping wearing a dudou, and it was automatically blocked. I then tried several other images that had previously gone through without difficulty, only to find that they too were now being intercepted. This suggests that censorship has now fully extended into private messaging as well. As AI technology improves, the cost of this surveillance and censorship will fall. The Party will no longer need to spend vast sums each year on manpower and so-called “stability maintenance”. Of course, this does not mean the money saved will be redirected into public welfare. The Party’s fundamental interest has never been the welfare of the people; it has always been the preservation of Communist rule. The people are, to the Party, much like toilet paper: useful when needed, disposable once used. And what better use for the money saved than locking up a few more troublesome dissidents and currying favour with the Party’s brothers-in-arms in its authoritarian camp?
Why am I unwilling to celebrate China’s technological progress? Because, in my view, the roots of the Chinese system are fundamentally warped, and so any technological development that grows from that soil will only travel further down the road of abetting tyranny. The more advanced the technology, the more hopeless the future for ordinary Chinese people. What does it matter if a company such as Huawei becomes the best in the world? Does that mean Chinese consumers will gain access to cheaper, better phones? Does it mean their privacy will be better protected? Neither. In a country where “the Party leads everything”, such firms will only work harder to defend the Party’s rule and to serve as its instruments for controlling the populace. That is both the first principle of their survival and the essential reason they are able to grow so large and powerful. That is why I regard China’s technological progress not with pride, but with profound sorrow.
(This article reflects the views of the author alone and does not necessarily represent those of this magazine or website.)
Comments