top of page

Hong Kong rejects US congressional commission’s criticism of security powers and press freedom

Writer: voiceofliberationu
voiceofliberationu
2 days ago
7 min read

HONG KONG, 20 November 2026 — The Hong Kong Government on Friday evening rejected a US congressional commission’s criticism of national security powers and press freedom in the city. In its annual report, the US-China Economic and Security Review Commission drew attention to the chief executive’s power to determine whether a criminal case involves national security and to police powers to demand device passwords. The government said the first measure clarified how cases were classified and the second required lawful authority to search. The two sides also differed over the treatment of journalists covering the Wang Fuk Court fire in Tai Po. [1] [2] [5]

The commission published its annual report in the United States on 18 November, with one chapter devoted to Hong Kong. Congress established the commission to examine the national security implications of bilateral trade and economic ties and to recommend legislative or administrative action. Beijing’s response came on 20 November. The Chinese foreign ministry’s office in Hong Kong issued its statement that afternoon. The territory’s government released its English statement at 9.41pm local time, or 1.41pm in London. [2] [16] [1] [4]

The commission considered the legal system alongside Hong Kong’s financial markets. It argued that the growing powers of the executive and security agencies had eroded the legal predictability that had attracted investors. Hong Kong’s government credited security legislation with restoring order and said residents continued to enjoy equality before the law and the protection of an independent judiciary. The foreign ministry’s office called the report interference in China’s internal affairs and said the legislation had strengthened protection for residents and the international community in Hong Kong. [3] [1] [4]

How a certificate changes the handling of a criminal case

One measure at issue had been in force for over five months. On 9 June the Chief Executive in Council made the Safeguarding National Security (Procedural Matters) Regulation under section 110 of the local security ordinance. It took effect on publication in the Gazette that day. The practical question was how the authorities should classify a case when a person is investigated, arrested or charged under another Hong Kong criminal law. [6] [7] [8]

Section 1 sets out two conditions. A person must be under investigation, arrest or charge for an offence arising from an act. The chief executive must also certify, under Article 47 of the National Security Law or section 115 of the local ordinance, that the act involves national security. The case then falls within Article 41 of the National Security Law. The certificate may be issued before or during proceedings. The regulation bars challenges to the certificate in court and legal action in respect of it. [6] [7]

The text expressly allows that classification even if the act or the prosecution predates the National Security Law. An alternative offence charged or proved in the same case in respect of the same act can also fall within the security framework for the relevant proceedings. The commission cited the reach of the chief executive’s decision into earlier events. The government stressed that the regulation introduced no offence, penalty or enforcement power. The legal consequences at issue are distinct. Applying a procedure to an earlier act raises a different question from criminalising conduct that was lawful when it occurred. [6] [7] [3]

The legislation provides a basis for distinguishing the two questions. Article 5 of the National Security Law preserves the presumption of innocence and the principle that an act must have constituted an offence when committed. Article 39 limits offences under that law to acts committed after it came into force. The June regulation expressly allows earlier conduct to trigger classification. Reading a case file therefore requires identifying both the substantive offence charged and the procedure that will govern the hearing. The certificate does not itself prove that the defendant did what is alleged. [8] [6]

For someone awaiting trial, classification can matter first of all to whether they can go home on bail. In its 9 February 2021 decision on Jimmy Lai’s bail, Hong Kong’s Court of Final Appeal explained that Article 42 of the National Security Law introduced a threshold. The judge must have sufficient grounds to believe the person would not continue to commit acts endangering national security. Only then does the court consider the ordinary bail criteria, including the risk of absconding or interfering with witnesses. The judge may take proposed bail conditions into account when assessing the threshold. [9] [8]

The court described the bail decision as a judicial assessment of future risk. At trial it remains for the prosecution to prove the charge. The government said on Friday that enforcement was based on conduct and evidence and that all defendants were entitled to a fair trial. The commission’s concern arises at an earlier stage. A defendant may contest the charge while having no route to challenge the certificate that determined the classification of the case. [9] [1] [6] [3]

When police can require a phone to be unlocked

A second dispute concerns private communications. In March, Hong Kong amended the implementation rules for Article 43 of the National Security Law. The government told legislators that officers already had lawful powers to search devices suspected of holding evidence, but lacked an express power to compel assistance with decryption. The amended Schedule 1 covers material stored on a device as well as material accessible through it. A phone containing few local files can therefore give access to material held elsewhere. [10] [1] [3]

Police need reasonable grounds to suspect that the device may hold evidence of a national security offence. The government reiterated on Friday that officers normally need a warrant from a magistrate. The paper submitted to legislators also records an exception where obtaining one would not be reasonably practicable. Once lawfully authorised to search, officers can require specified people to provide a necessary password, a decryption method or other assistance that is reasonably necessary. They may include a suspect, but also someone reasonably believed to own, control or have used the device, or to know the password. [10] [1]

The penalties distinguish between two acts. Failure to comply without reasonable excuse carries a maximum fine of HK$100,000 and one year in prison. Knowingly or recklessly giving materially false or misleading information carries a maximum of HK$500,000 and three years. The government paper also distinguishes compliance from the information recovered. Subject to statutory conditions, there are limits on using the fact that someone supplied a password against that person in criminal proceedings. Those limits do not automatically extend to the material obtained from the device. [10]

These distinctions matter to communications between journalists and their sources. A search may reach material concerning people other than the device holder, and authority to search must precede a demand for decryption. The UK Government also recorded the March amendments in its six-monthly report on Hong Kong. The provisions and official accounts establish the scope of the power. They do not establish that it was used against a particular reporter’s phone or that any source was identified as a result. [10] [15] [1]

The dispute over coverage of the Wang Fuk Court fire

The commission cited the November 2025 fire at Wang Fuk Court as evidence that national security agencies’ attention had extended to coverage of a major public safety disaster. The blaze killed 168 people. Residents and reporters sought answers about oversight of renovations and the response to the fire. On 6 December 2025, Beijing’s national security office in Hong Kong said it had summoned representatives of foreign media and warned against spreading what the authorities described as false information. News organisations reported the meeting at the time. The Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism at Oxford also documented it in a report published in June. [3] [12] [11]

The government said on Friday that it had continued its work after the fire and accused people of using online messages and leaflets to misrepresent rescue efforts and provoke division. It said journalists were free to comment on and criticise government policies within the law. The South China Morning Post also identified fire coverage as a point of contention. The public record confirms the meeting and warning. Neither side’s latest account identifies, story by story, which reports were inaccurate or which interviews were dropped because of the warning. [1] [5] [11]

For residents, the question extends beyond possible penalties for reporters to the information they can obtain from different sources. Article 27 of the Basic Law protects freedom of speech, of the press and of publication. Article 30 protects the freedom and privacy of communications and sets conditions for their lawful inspection. Article 39 keeps the relevant international covenants in force as applied to Hong Kong. The government invoked these protections and the scope for necessary restrictions prescribed by law. The Reuters Institute, meanwhile, documented how journalists weighed legal risks, including through self-censorship. The two accounts address the legal guarantee and the practical decision about whether a story will appear. [13] [12] [1]

The commission also noted a legal remedy available to journalists. On 10 September, the Eastern Magistrates’ Courts ruled on a private prosecution brought by journalist Selina Cheng against her former employer, Dow Jones Publishing Company (Asia). The employer was convicted on the charge of deterring her from standing for chair of the Hong Kong Journalists Association and acquitted on a separate charge relating to her subsequent dismissal. The court considered separately what the employer did before the election and why it later ended her employment. Proof of the first offence did not establish the second. [17] [3]

What the market figures show

The commission acknowledged Hong Kong’s ability to attract listings but offered a different reading of the growth. Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing recorded 87 listings raising HK$210.2 billion through initial public offerings in the first half of the year, up 92.1 per cent on the same period in 2025. The commission focused on the issuers. It calculated that mainland companies accounted for 96 per cent of Hong Kong IPOs by number over the half-year. The two percentages measure different things, one a change in funds raised and the other the share of issuers. [14] [2] [3]

The Hong Kong Government emphasised the city’s role in linking mainland and international markets and said about 1,550 US companies operated there. The foreign ministry’s office cited financial-centre and competitiveness rankings as signs of Hong Kong’s continuing appeal overseas. The exchange’s figures document an active market for listings. For someone applying for bail after arrest, or a journalist preparing an investigation, the more immediate questions concern the threshold a court applies, the conditions on police authority and whether a newsroom can continue pursuing a matter of public interest. [1] [4] [14] [9] [12]

Sources

 
 
 

Recent Posts

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page