top of page

A Comment on Mr Wang Xizhe’s Speech at the Founding Conference of the European Headquarters of China Democracy Party

Writer: Min Cheng
Min Cheng
May 13
4 min read

Updated: Nov 13

On 10 May, as a member of the UK Headquarters of the China Democracy Party, I attended the “Founding Conference of the European Headquarters of the China Democracy Party”. Quite a number of well-known figures from the overseas Chinese pro-democracy movement were present. Almost every guest delivered a speech. Some spoke with maturity and composure about the history of the movement; some looked ahead to the future of democracy in China; and Hong Kong democrats also shared their own experiences of persecution. Overall, I found the event highly rewarding.


There was, however, one elderly gentleman whose speech, lasting more than twenty minutes — perhaps even longer — struck me as deeply problematic. During the question-and-answer session, I was unable to express my views for personal reasons. I am therefore writing this comment today for that veteran heavyweight of the overseas pro-democracy community: Mr Wang Xizhe.


Since Mr Wang’s speech was extremely long, and since my own memory is hardly perfect, it would be impossible for me to rebut every point he made. I will therefore address only two points that left a strong impression on me. My quotations may differ from his exact wording, but I will do my best to avoid distorting his original meaning.


First: “My position is consistent with that of Taiwan’s Kuomintang: cross-Strait exchanges, in order to promote — or, one might say, force — the Chinese Communist Party to carry out democratic reform. If the CCP refuses to accept this, then it will be acting against the tide of history.”


To be frank, had I not heard this in person, I would have found it difficult to imagine such a view coming from an elderly man who has spent his entire life in the pro-democracy movement. I would first like to remind Mr Wang of two basic facts.


The Chinese Communist Party is not a modern political party in the ordinary sense. It is a one-party dictatorship that combines Marxism with China’s traditional imperial and feudal political structures. The core purpose of CCP rule is singular: to preserve the authoritarian rule and political security of the red regime.


The core instruments of CCP rule are violence, lies and indoctrination. These three reinforce one another and, under the façade of “rule of law”, sustain the stability of the CCP’s power.


I would therefore like to ask Mr Wang a question. As a senior figure who has spent a lifetime in the pro-democracy movement, and as a witness to the Tiananmen massacre, on what basis do you believe that a CCP whose central purpose is to maintain its hold on power, and which relies on lies, violence and indoctrination to do so, would give up that power and carry out democratic reform simply because of some so-called democratic trend?


International condemnation? If the CCP feared condemnation, the Tiananmen massacre would never have happened, the Hong Kong National Security Law would never have been imposed, and countless dissidents would never have been imprisoned for their words.

The CCP’s fundamental problem does not merely lie in its unwillingness to reform. Its political legitimacy itself rests on lies and violence under one-party dictatorship. Once genuine press freedom, judicial independence and competitive elections are introduced, the foundations of its rule will collapse. For the CCP, therefore, “democratic reform” is a fatal poison. To expect some supposed democratic tide to force the CCP to yield and carry out democratic reform can only be described as the romanticism of an older generation of pro-democracy activists.


Second: “Please do not oppose the Communist Party in the name of the Democracy Party. The China Democracy Party does not have an anti-Communist slogan.”

As a member of the Democracy Party, I find this statement equally unacceptable. In my view, a slogan is not the party constitution. It is not a solemn document setting out the party’s programme, principles and objectives. More often, it is one or two short, clear and memorable lines that people think of at an event for a specific purpose. There are no rigid rules for it. At most, one should avoid abuse and vulgar language.


In China, support for democracy and opposition to the Communist Party are naturally united. Mr Wang tells us not to oppose the Communist Party in the name of the Democracy Party. Then I will also tell him this: as a member of the China Democracy Party, I will chant anti-Communist slogans, and I will do so precisely in the name of a member of the Democracy Party.


Mr Wang also made many other bizarre remarks that day, including claims such as “Taiwan independence supporters are descendants of imperial subjects”, “Taiwan independence is an act of fleeing”, and expressions of support for armed unification with Taiwan. For reasons of space, I do not intend to respond to each of these in turn.


I will say only this: Mr Wang Xizhe, you do not represent the China Democracy Party. Please stop treating your status as a founding elder of the party as licence to speak recklessly. You are indeed a founding elder, and for that very reason, others will naturally associate your words with the position of the Democracy Party. Every sensational statement you make damages more than your own credibility. It harms the image and credibility of the entire Democracy Party.


So, in future, please be more cautious when you speak. Do not make ordinary members of the Democracy Party bear the consequences of your unwarranted remarks.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

Comments


bottom of page