top of page

China, Russia and the US stress officials’ immunity in Shenzhen declaration on the ICC

Writer: voiceofliberationu
voiceofliberationu
3 days ago
8 min read

SHENZHEN, 19 November 2026 — Chinese President Xi Jinping, Russian President Vladimir Putin and US President Donald Trump issued a four-point declaration in Shenzhen today that devoted an entire paragraph to the International Criminal Court (ICC). They emphasised state consent and respect for the immunities of state officials and called on the ICC and similar bodies to avoid abusing their jurisdiction. Putin was at the table while subject to an ICC arrest warrant. The declaration neither named that warrant nor identified a case in which the three governments believed the court had overstepped its powers. Declaration published by China Declaration published by the White House Associated Press reporting from Shenzhen

In Brussels, European Commission spokesperson Christian Wigand told reporters the Commission had only just seen the declaration and was following the outcome of the talks. He reiterated the EU’s view that the ICC is fundamental to a rules-based international order. In New York, Farhan Haq, deputy spokesperson for the UN Secretary-General, also voiced support for the court and left questions about its handling of cases to the court itself. European Commission briefing, 19 November Anadolu report on the UN briefing

What the three leaders agreed

The three leaders met for more than an hour at Shenzhen’s Kylin Villa, the Associated Press reported. China and the White House listed the countries in different orders in their English versions of the declaration but used the same substantive wording on the court. The four points cover UN reform, the production and supply of refined petroleum products, state consent and official immunities, and the reduction of nuclear risks. Neither text defines an abuse of jurisdiction. Neither mentions the case concerning Ukrainian children, an amendment to the court’s statute or the reversal of a judicial decision. Declaration published by China Declaration published by the White House Associated Press reporting from Shenzhen

Xi offered a positive assessment afterwards. According to Chinese reporting cited by AP, he said the countries shared a view about safeguarding peace, should take states’ legitimate security concerns seriously and should settle differences through negotiation and cooperation. Putin spoke at the start of the meeting about their responsibilities for international peace and security. Trump presented the encounter as a beginning for discussions on difficult issues. Those remarks explain how each leader framed the meeting. Their common position on the court is recorded in the third point of the declaration. Associated Press reporting from Shenzhen Declaration published by China

All three countries are permanent members of the UN Security Council. None is a party to the Rome Statute, the treaty establishing the ICC. The two roles carry different powers. The Security Council can refer a situation to the prosecutor when acting under Chapter VII of the UN Charter. A text issued jointly by three permanent members does not constitute a Council resolution. Article 16 of the Statute provides a separate route for the Council to request a twelve-month deferral of an investigation or prosecution. That too requires a resolution. UN treaty depositary records Rome Statute on jurisdiction and admissibility Declaration published by China

Why the warrant for Putin matters

An ICC pre-trial chamber issued the warrant for Putin on 17 March 2023. The allegations concern the unlawful deportation and transfer of children from occupied parts of Ukraine. At the warrant stage the judges consider whether there are reasonable grounds to believe the suspect committed the alleged offences. Neither the issuance of a warrant nor the subsequent disputes over its execution determine individual criminal responsibility at trial. ICC decision on Mongolia EU statement on the warrant and the visit to Mongolia Associated Press reporting from Shenzhen

The difference in standards is substantial. Under Article 58, judges examine the prosecution’s evidence and other material. They must also decide whether arrest appears necessary, for instance to secure the person’s appearance. Article 66 places the burden of proving guilt on the prosecution and requires the court to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt before convicting anyone. Putin’s presence in Shenzhen shows that he attended the meeting. It supplies no answer to the allegations and gives no grounds for saying they have been withdrawn. Rome Statute on investigation and arrest Rome Statute on trials and victims’ rights Associated Press reporting from Shenzhen

State consent can take different legal forms. Under Article 12, where a state party refers a situation or the prosecutor initiates proceedings, the territorial state or the state of nationality of the accused can satisfy the relevant precondition by becoming a party or making a declaration accepting jurisdiction. The Ukraine proceedings illustrate the distinction. Ukraine accepted jurisdiction over relevant crimes on its territory before it became a state party. The treaty entered into force for Ukraine on 1 January 2025, after the warrants were issued. Rome Statute on jurisdiction and admissibility UN treaty depositary records Ukrainian UN delegation on its acceptance of jurisdiction

A separate body of evidence concerns the children and their families. In March the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry on Ukraine said it had verified the deportation or transfer of 1,205 children from occupied Ukrainian territory to Russia or to other occupied parts of Ukraine. It concluded that the deportation and forcible transfer, and the enforced disappearance of children, amounted to crimes against humanity. The figure covers the cases it verified. The commission reports to the UN Human Rights Council. Its findings about a pattern of conduct are distinct from a criminal court’s determination of an individual’s responsibility. UN Ukraine commission of inquiry briefing Commission of inquiry report to the Human Rights Council

Commissioner Pablo de Greiff told a Geneva press conference that Russian authorities had described the movements as humanitarian evacuations for the children’s safety. Investigators followed up on what happened to the children. About four in five in the documented cases had not returned when the commission reported in March, and many parents and guardians did not know where their children were. Investigators described arrangements for long-term placement with families or institutions across parts of Russia and occupied Ukraine. The proportion applies to the cases examined at that time. It is not a current estimate for all missing children. UN Ukraine commission of inquiry briefing Commission of inquiry report to the Human Rights Council

For families trying to trace a child, one question is whether the people affected can be heard. Article 68 allows victims whose personal interests are affected to present their views and concerns at stages the court considers appropriate, including through legal representatives where permitted. The judges must protect victims’ and witnesses’ safety, dignity and privacy while safeguarding the rights of the accused and a fair trial. Participation cannot guarantee that a particular child will be found or substitute for practical help in tracing and reuniting families. Rome Statute on trials and victims’ rights Commission of inquiry report to the Human Rights Council

How a warrant is enforced

The Statute deals separately with liability in office and the duty to deliver someone to the court. Article 27 provides that official capacity, including as a head of state, does not exempt a person from criminal responsibility under the Statute. Immunities attaching to the office do not bar the court from exercising jurisdiction. Article 86 requires states parties to cooperate fully under the Statute. A request to a particular state still raises questions about that state’s obligations, the person whose surrender is sought and whether a third state must waive an immunity. Rome Statute on responsibility and official capacity Rome Statute on judicial cooperation

The issue arose in practice when Putin visited Mongolia in September 2024. Mongolia, a state party, had received a cooperation request and did not arrest him. In written observations it invoked the immunity of an incumbent foreign head of state and argued that the court had to take account of Mongolia’s international obligations towards a third state when requesting an arrest. In Mongolia’s submission, Russia had never joined the Statute, so a waiver of immunity by Russia could not simply be assumed. Mongolia’s observations to the court ICC decision on Mongolia

On 24 October that year the pre-trial chamber rejected that argument. In proceedings before the ICC, it held, Putin’s status as head of state supplied no basis for refusing to execute the warrant, and Russia did not need to waive immunity for that request to be enforced. It found that Mongolia had failed to cooperate and referred the matter to the Assembly of States Parties. The ruling addressed a specific request to a treaty party. The Shenzhen declaration does not engage with the chamber’s reasoning or ask the Assembly to take any action. ICC decision on Mongolia Rome Statute on judicial cooperation Declaration published by China

The dispute turned on a procedural condition in Article 98. If complying with a surrender request would breach the requested state’s obligations towards a third state concerning immunity, the court must first obtain the third state’s cooperation in waiving that immunity. The provision does not itself list every person who enjoys immunity in every setting. Mongolia and the judges considered the same article and came to opposite conclusions about whether the condition applied to this request. Rome Statute on judicial cooperation Mongolia’s observations to the court ICC decision on Mongolia

The Mongolian proceedings also show why hosting Putin in China does not by itself reproduce the legal question Mongolia faced. China is not a state party. The general duty of cooperation that the Statute imposes on its parties cannot simply be transposed to China because a visit took place there. The Statute separately permits the court to invite a non-party to assist on the basis of an ad hoc arrangement, an agreement or another appropriate basis. A claim about a specific duty in connection with a visit requires an identifiable request and legal basis as well as an outstanding warrant. Rome Statute on judicial cooperation UN treaty depositary records Mongolia’s observations to the court

The UN and EU responses

According to Anadolu’s report of the UN briefing, Haq said the Secretary-General regarded the ICC as crucial to international justice. The UN has a relationship agreement with the court and wants member states to support its work, he said. Asked about a leader subject to a warrant taking part in decisions about the court, he said it was for the court to discuss its own work. By 8 pm London time, no statement from the ICC specifically addressing the Shenzhen declaration had been located in the public material reviewed for this report. Anadolu report on the UN briefing European Commission briefing, 19 November

In Brussels, Wigand likewise set limits on what the Commission was prepared to say that day. He expressed support for the UN Secretary-General’s reform agenda and reiterated the EU’s support for the ICC. The leaders addressed UN reform and international criminal justice in the same document, but the legal processes involved are distinct. Their declaration did not present a Security Council resolution to defer proceedings or identify any judicial process to be changed. Its immediate effect was to put on record a common position on official immunities from three permanent members of the Council. European Commission briefing, 19 November Declaration published by the White House Rome Statute on jurisdiction and admissibility

Sources

 
 
 

Recent Posts

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page