top of page

Hong Kong passes criminal hearsay reform with national security cases excluded

Writer: voiceofliberationu
voiceofliberationu
4 days ago
7 min read

Hong Kong, 18 November 2026 — Hong Kong’s Legislative Council today passed the Evidence (Amendment) Bill 2026 at its third reading. In criminal proceedings covered by the reform, either side will be able to ask a court to hear an earlier account from a witness who has died or is too unwell to testify. Where the application is contested, the judge must examine why the witness is unavailable and whether the account is reliable. The scheme excludes cases concerning national security. Its commencement date will be announced in the Gazette. Bills Committee chair on the third reading (Chinese) Motion for third reading (Chinese) Government statement on gazettal Secretary for Justice’s second-reading speech (Chinese)

Carmen Kan, who chaired the Bills Committee, confirmed the outcome in an account published on Wednesday. Over four meetings with the government, the committee considered how courts could hear evidence they might otherwise have to exclude while protecting an accused person’s opportunity to challenge the witness. Secretary for Justice Paul Lam told legislators that children, people with intellectual disabilities and people who had experienced severe trauma could all have evidence to give yet be unable to testify. Bills Committee chair on the third reading (Chinese) Secretary for Justice’s second-reading speech (Chinese)

Why a recorded interview can still be excluded

Hearsay has a particular legal meaning. Suppose a police officer tells the court that someone described an incident they had witnessed. The officer can answer questions about what was said. If the account is offered to prove that the incident happened, however, the other side cannot ask the absent eyewitness what they could actually see or how well they remember it. A recording can establish the words used while leaving the accuracy of the underlying account open to challenge. Law Reform Commission report Department of Justice on the care-home prosecution

A prosecution involving a residential care home for people with disabilities brought the distinction into public view. Explaining its decision to withdraw the case in 2016, the Department of Justice said prosecutors had arranged a video interview with the complainant in 2014 and sought permission to use it. Even with permission, the statutory procedure on which they relied required them to call her so the defence had an opportunity to cross-examine her. Recording the interview in the prescribed manner fulfilled only one part of that process. Department of Justice on the care-home prosecution

Prosecutors sought four adjournments to allow the complainant time to recover and obtained specialist medical reports on six occasions. According to the department, she remained unfit to testify. One specialist warned that compelling her to appear could jeopardise her recovery. After reassessing the remaining evidence, prosecutors concluded that it offered no reasonable prospect of conviction and withdrew the case. The decision illustrates how rules of evidence can determine whether allegations ever reach a trial on the facts. There was no judicial finding that the allegations were proved. Department of Justice on the care-home prosecution

The case for reform predates that prosecution. In November 2009 the Law Reform Commission found that, although the existing rule protected the opportunity for cross-examination, its exceptions were complex and could exclude accounts that there was good reason to trust. Defendants could bear the cost too. If a witness who could support an alibi died before trial, for example, the defence might lose the opportunity to put that account before the court. Law Reform Commission report Government statement on gazettal

An earlier bill introduced in 2018 lapsed when the legislative term ended before scrutiny was complete. The department revisited the commission’s proposals, responses to consultation and the legislature’s earlier deliberations. The new bill was gazetted on 12 June. The government’s English statement at the time expressly excluded cases concerning national security. The provisions passed today therefore do not establish how an out-of-court account would be treated in such a case. Government statement on gazettal Secretary for Justice’s second-reading speech (Chinese)

When the parties disagree about admitting a statement

Existing statutory provisions and preserved common law exceptions will continue to operate. The new scheme provides three further routes. The parties can expressly agree to admit a statement. Alternatively, the party wishing to use it can give notice and the statement can be admitted if nobody serves notice of opposition. The distinction matters to a defendant reading such a notice. The second route can apply even if the defendant has never positively agreed to admission. Government statement on gazettal Secretary for Justice’s second-reading speech (Chinese)

Where a party objects, a third route requires the party seeking to use the evidence to obtain the court’s permission. The court must assess necessity, whether there is reasonable assurance that the statement is reliable, and whether its value in proving a disputed fact outweighs the prejudice it might cause to any party. Establishing that a witness has died explains the absence. The judge must still examine what the person said, the circumstances in which they said it and the consequences of losing the chance to question them. Secretary for Justice’s second-reading speech (Chinese) Law Reform Commission report

Unavailability has a practical meaning. Lam said that if the person was outside Hong Kong, the applicant would have to show why it was not reasonably practicable to arrange for evidence to be given by another permitted means. If the witness could not be found, all reasonable steps to locate them must have been taken. Where age or health was at issue, fitness to testify included the ability to give evidence by other permitted means. Reluctance or inconvenience alone would not satisfy those requirements. Secretary for Justice’s second-reading speech (Chinese) Committee-stage amendments (Chinese)

A witness abroad may be entirely willing to give evidence and still be beyond the means of an ordinary household. The Law Society noted that the cost of taking evidence overseas could be prohibitive for a defendant, with or without legal aid. The department replied that a test of reasonable practicability allowed for travel, accommodation and other arrangements. A permitted remote hearing, for example, could preserve the opportunity for both sides to put questions directly. The cost and practical options would need to be considered in the individual case. Law Society submissions and departmental responses Secretary for Justice’s second-reading speech (Chinese)

An amendment made at committee stage clarified who must prove what. The applicant has to establish one of the specified reasons why the maker of the statement cannot testify. Prosecutors must do so beyond reasonable doubt. A defendant need only show that the explanation is more likely than not. That lower standard concerns the defence application to admit evidence. The prosecution retains the burden of proving guilt. Committee-stage amendments (Chinese)

A separate question arises if an applicant, or someone acting on the applicant’s behalf, deliberately brought about the witness’s unavailability through an act or omission intended to prevent oral testimony. The applicant cannot then rely on that absence to establish necessity. The party alleging interference must prove it, beyond reasonable doubt if it is the prosecution and on the balance of probabilities if it is the accused. Lam said this avoided requiring every applicant to establish the negative proposition that nobody on their side had prevented the witness from appearing. Committee-stage amendments (Chinese) Secretary for Justice’s second-reading speech (Chinese)

How a defendant without a lawyer can object

The Law Society of Hong Kong supported reform in principle but warned during consultation that the way procedures worked in practice could affect the ability to mount a defence. It asked how prosecutors would reach an agreement with an unrepresented accused and whether advance notice from the defence might disclose its approach prematurely. These were comments on the consultation draft. The department subsequently provided legislators with an English account of the submissions and its responses. Law Society consultation summary Law Society submissions and departmental responses

A notice familiar to a solicitor may reach a person defending themselves who has no idea that a response is needed. In its consultation reply, the department pointed to prosecutors’ obligations under the Prosecution Code when dealing with unrepresented people, and to the court’s duty to ensure fairness. Lam told legislators on Wednesday that courts could vary notice periods and, where appropriate, allow notice to be given orally in court. Judges would also provide guidance so that an accused could seek admission or object. Law Society submissions and departmental responses Secretary for Justice’s second-reading speech (Chinese)

Advance notice also affects the preparation of co-defendants. In its reply to the Law Society, the department explained that if one accused introduced a statement unexpectedly at trial, others might need time to investigate and respond, potentially requiring an adjournment. The profession’s concerns about time, cost and resources, and the department’s wish to identify disputes early, turn on a practical question. Does a person who receives notice actually have time to find the original record, check the account and decide how to respond? Law Society submissions and departmental responses Law Society consultation summary

The Law Society offered a hypothetical case involving two defendants. One had said that they alone committed the offence. If a court had already excluded that statement as involuntary, could the second defendant still seek to use it to show they took no part? The department considered permission unlikely. The circumstances in which the statement was made bore directly on its reliability, and its use might prejudice the first defendant. The example tested the draft in consultation. A ruling on the facts would be for the trial judge. Law Society submissions and departmental responses

Even after a disputed statement has been admitted, its weight remains to be assessed alongside the other evidence. Another witness might give a different account, or a contemporaneous record might change how a statement is understood. Lam said either side could ask the court to reconsider admission as the trial progressed. Particular attention would be paid to the disadvantage to a defendant unable to question the original speaker. In the interests of justice, the court could exclude the statement and order a retrial. Secretary for Justice’s second-reading speech (Chinese) Law Reform Commission report

For those preparing cases, the next practical step is the Judiciary’s practice directions. Lam said these would set out the detailed procedures for matters such as notices and applications. Once preparations are complete, the Secretary for Justice will appoint a commencement date by notice in the Gazette. The Council’s decision on 18 November settles the legislative vote. The date on which a party can first apply under the new scheme depends on that commencement notice. Bills Committee chair on the third reading (Chinese) Secretary for Justice’s second-reading speech (Chinese) Government statement on gazettal

Sources

 
 
 

Recent Posts

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page